maze animate side-by-side
Circuit
Comparison (+Circuit)
Urban Traffic
張老師與他的科技英文與科普傳播 Technical English for Engineering Students Using Claude
AI for solving amplifier electronics (課堂講義)
建議工具
使用 Gemini 3 Pro 免費額度最高 1M tokens
使用 Grok 4
Content share
課堂練習
Deadline: This Saturday at 23:59
Send all the share links to me chang212@gmail.com by email with subject EX#1 [your id, your name]
How to publish a Claude artifact
任選做一題
1. Lab Activity: 為什麼我的 AI 跟你不一樣?
2. Lab Activity: Amplifier Gain & Frequency Response Using AI-Assisted Analysis
3. Make the Bode plot of Circuit in Example 1, as below You must verify the results for correctness.
The results must be scientifically accurate.
4. With the following circuit and its Bode plot
Hints
Use A* to design a class AB amplifier. The first stage is class A. the second is class B. freq response cut off at 10Hz and 25 KHz
advanced version A* search for optimization, share 4-parameter
_______________________________________________
demo, no A*
Solve for the gain, plot freq response.
.
Gemini 2.5 Pro gain & lower cut off freq match Claude, 4kHz
Miller approximation error since it ignores pole interaction effects
Analysis with Cπ = 22.1 pF, Cμ = 3.0 pF
Solve for the gain. Plot frequency response for the following amplifier circuit.
_______________
History
AI Model Results:
Note: Lower cut-off comes from coupling capacitors (not shown here). assuming 1.0 μF
Generate professional grade Bode plot.
generate professional plot using Matplotlib
1. React (Claude) - AIStudio - Python w/ Matplotlib - Colab - Plot
2. Reasoning (AIStudio) - AIStudio - Python w/ Matplotlib - Colab - Plot
我用Claude計算電晶體放大器,得出頻率響應理論值 2.4 MHz。然後我給他一組Grok 算出來的數據是 125 kHz,兩者差了20倍。
我沒有跟Claude 說這組數據哪裡來的,他稱讚我的數據是應該是用Spice 專業軟體跑出來的,而且提醒我他的計算是根據純理論,因為Spice 可以考慮更多細節去電路模擬,所以Claude認為我的數據比較值得參考。
接下來我跟他講這組數據是 Grok 4 算的,Claude 馬上變換語氣,說頻率響應不可能是125 kHz,業界標準至少在1 MHz 以上,說Grok:
可是剛剛不是還在稱讚「我的模擬」做得好?以前Claude 還會稱讚別家的AI有什麼優勢,現在看起來不演了。
Advanced visualization with backtrack included and transit animated (Data visualization techniques)
______________________________
History
Build A* tree synced with animation